Player Profile

McCae Hillstead

QB • 5'10" • 195 lbs • Lehi, UT, USA

Balanced quarterback profileVolume operator

McCae Hillstead is a balanced quarterback profile with 3.5 usage in the latest tracked season.

Usage Score

3.5

Efficiency

33.5

Consistency

12.7

Season Value

13.8

Career Arc

Season-by-season value trend

Best season by value score: 2023 Postseason · Utah State

2323242525

Quick Facts

Career Teams
2
Seasons Tracked
5
Primary stop by seasons
Utah State
Best season by value score
Best season by value score: 2023 Postseason · Utah State
Peak game by takeover score
Peak game by takeover score: Unknown

McCae Hillstead, QB. Best season Best season by value score: 2023 Postseason · Utah State. McCae Hillstead is a balanced quarterback profile with 3.5 usage in the latest tracked season.

Player insights

Lead takeaway

Best season by value score: 2023 Postseason

Utah State paired 1,098 primary output with 53.1 efficiency.

Supporting note

2025 Postseason role shape

pass-led usage with 33.5 efficiency.

Supporting note

Career value stayed steady

2025 Regular Season tracked close to the prior stop by season value score.

Supporting note

Multi-stop career journey

Production spans 2 team stops, with role shifts visible across Utah State, BYU.

Supporting note

Peak game by takeover score: Unknown

Game with 56 yards of offense and 83.8 efficiency. It landed in the 100th percentile of the selected season.

Season Explorer

Understand the selected season before dropping into the full game log.

2025 Postseason · BYU

Games

4

Primary Metric / G

15.3

Efficiency

33.5

Usage

3.5

Consistency

12.7

Best Game by takeover score

Georgia Tech

Hover a point or expand a game row to keep the active game context visible here.

Game-by-Game Trend

1234

Chronological game order.

Game by game trend chart. Georgia Tech: 1. Unknown: 56. East Carolina: 3. UCF: 1

Volume vs Efficiency

Low volume / high quality

High volume / high quality

Low volume / lower quality

High volume / lower quality

Volume on the x-axis, quality on the y-axis.

Volume versus efficiency scatter chart. Georgia Tech: 1 by 10. Unknown: 7 by 83.8. East Carolina: 1 by 30. UCF: 1 by 10

Split Comparison

Wins1.7 · n=3
First Half28.5 · n=2 · +26.5 vs Second Half
Second Half2 · n=2 · -26.5 vs First Half
All Games15.3 · n=4

Game Log

Dense stat lines with inline explanations and season-linked highlights.

4 games

Featured metric

Total Offense

Top game by takeover score

Unknown

Best efficiency game

83.8 vs Unknown

Result
Sat 12/27vs Georgia TechW 25-211011101
Sat 11/29vs UCFW 41-211011101
Sat 9/20@ East CarolinaW 34-133013303
Sun 8/31vs Unknown453380.00083.822311.50013

Career Arc

Track team changes, role shifts, and season-to-season movement.

  1. 1

    Utah State

    2023

    Opening stop

  2. 2

    BYU

    2024-2025

    Final stop

Season Progression

20232023202420252025
SeasonTeamPrimaryEfficiencyUsageDelta
2023 PostseasonUtah State1,09853.116.4
2023 Regular SeasonUtah State1,09853.116.40
2024 Regular SeasonBYU0-1,098
2025 PostseasonBYU6133.53.561
2025 Regular SeasonBYU6133.53.50

Signature Performances

Top Games

#1 Featured game

Unknown

Game with 56 yards of offense and 83.8 efficiency.

56

Primary metric

56 total offense with 83.8 efficiency.

#2

James Madison

373

Primary metric

Loss shaped by high passing volume and turnover pressure.

373 total offense with 49.6 efficiency.

#3

Air Force

208

Primary metric

Loss with 208 yards of offense and 59.4 efficiency.

208 total offense with 59.4 efficiency.

#4

San José State

170

Primary metric

Loss shaped by high passing volume and turnover pressure.

170 total offense with 47.4 efficiency.

#5

UConn

137

Primary metric

Win shaped by high passing volume and turnover pressure.

137 total offense with 52.3 efficiency.

Top Seasons

#1 Season by value score

2023 Postseason · Utah State

1,098 primary output · 53.1 efficiency · 16.4 usage

54.8

#2

2023 Regular Season · Utah State

54.8

1,098 primary · 53.1 efficiency · 16.4 usage

#3

2025 Postseason · BYU

13.8

61 primary · 33.5 efficiency · 3.5 usage

Milestones

1

250+ passing yards

1

300+ total offense

0

3+ takeover TD games

2

Above avg efficiency

Bio, Recruit, and Data Context

Recruit Profile

3★

Class 2023 · Rating 0.8433

Skyridge · Lehi, UT

Committed To
Utah State
Commit Date
Jan 1, 2023

Career Facts

2

Career teams

5

Seasons tracked

1,159

Career Total Offense

Data Context

Coverage spans 5 tracked seasons, 12 games, and SP opponent-strength context when available. Derived metrics fall back to raw production when share or rating context is missing.

Career Metric Focus

Switch the career lens without tearing down the page.

Quick Answers

McCae Hillstead quick answers

Recruiting profile

3-star recruit

Position
QB
Teams played for
2
Seasons tracked
5
Career passing yards
1,095